Plumber in St. James City and Bokeelia

Leer esta página en español · Ler esta página em português

HomeFlow Plumbing works at both ends of Pine Island: the canal streets of St. James City in the south and Bokeelia up on Charlotte Harbor. These are septic communities on long drives from the mainland, with a lot of older homes, mobile homes and post-Ian rebuilds. Call (239) 518-4198 and tell us which end you’re on.

Plumbing Services in St. James City and Bokeelia

Residential

Leaks, drains, water heaters and repipes for St. James City and Bokeelia homes.

Commercial

Service and repairs for offices, retail and other commercial buildings in St. James City and Bokeelia.

Remodels

Bathroom and kitchen remodels, and repiping while the walls are open.

New Construction

Plumbing for new homes and commercial builds in and around St. James City and Bokeelia.

Two ends of the same island

St. James City and Bokeelia are both unincorporated communities on Pine Island in Lee County, but they sit at opposite tips and they don’t have much in common beyond Stringfellow Road. St. James City is the census area covering the southern half of the island, bordered by San Carlos Bay to the south and Pine Island Sound to the west. Bokeelia is the north end, with water on three sides: Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor and Matlacha Pass.

The numbers from the 2020 census tell you a lot about the plumbing work. St. James City had 3,876 residents, a median age of 66.7 and 3,467 housing units, nearly 40 percent of them listed as vacant. Bokeelia had 1,855 residents, a median age of 60 and 1,387 housing units, with about 39 percent vacant. In both places that vacancy figure is mostly seasonal and second homes. Both sit at an elevation of about 7 feet.

Our Pine Island and Matlacha plumber page covers the island as a whole. This page goes into what’s different at the two ends, because a call from a canal street in St. James City and a call from a mobile home park in Bokeelia usually turn into very different jobs.

St. James CityBokeelia
WhereSouthern half of Pine Island, town center at the south tipNorth tip, including Bokeelia Island across a short bridge
2020 population3,8761,855
Housing units / share vacant3,467 / 39.6%1,387 / 38.9%
Typical housingCanal homes from the postwar canal era, mobile homes, post-Ian elevated rebuildsOlder cottages, manufactured home parks, rural lots, newer homes on pilings
Open water exposureSan Carlos Bay, Pine Island Sound, deep-dug canalsCharlotte Harbor, Pine Island Sound, Matlacha Pass
Water / wastewaterGreater Pine Island Water Association; mostly septicGreater Pine Island Water Association; mostly septic

St. James City: an 1880s street grid with 1950s canals

St. James City is older than it looks. The St. James-on-the-Gulf Corporation was incorporated in 1885 and owned close to 3,900 acres on the south end of the island. It laid out a town grid north to Eighth Avenue, between Coconut Street and Sanibel Boulevard, with streets surfaced in shell. That grid is still the bones of the old town center.

Most of the houses we work on came later. Starting in the 1950s, developer Tom Phillips dug the canals around St. James City, and the subdivisions that grew along them went by names like Pine Island Shores, Gulf-Haven and St. Jude Harbor. Lee County planning work for the island counts about 66 miles of canal banks on Pine Island, and a large share of them are here. Monroe Canal, one of the main waterways through the south end, took some of the worst of Hurricane Ian.

What that means at the plumbing level:

  • Many houses are on narrow canal lots with the septic tank and drainfield squeezed between the house and the seawall. There isn’t much room to relocate anything.
  • Homes built in the 1960s and 1970s often still have original cast iron or early plastic drain lines under the slab, plus copper or galvanized supply lines that have been patched over the years.
  • A lot of houses have been added onto. We regularly find a bathroom or laundry tied into a drain that was never sized for it.
  • Mobile homes and RVs sit on lots throughout the area, some as full-time homes and some as fish camps.

If you’re buying on a canal in St. James City, our guide to buying an older home lists the plumbing questions worth asking before you close.

Bokeelia: harbor exposure and manufactured home parks

Bokeelia’s original settlement is on Bokeelia Island, which connects to Pine Island by a short bridge on Stringfellow Road. From there it’s about 7 miles south to Pine Island Center. The Padilla family, one of Lee County’s pioneer families, still lives here, and the north end has a working fishing village feel that the south end mostly lost to canal development.

The census counts Bokeelia as entirely rural. Housing is a mix of old cottages close to the water, homes on larger lots inland, and several manufactured home communities. One of them, The Palms at Pine Island, has about 144 units and was rebuilt in apartment-style trailers after Hurricane Charley in 2004. Charley made landfall just across the sound at Cayo Costa, so the north end has now been through two major storms in under 20 years.

The plumbing calls we see in Bokeelia lean toward supply lines under manufactured homes, water heaters in exterior closets, long buried service lines on bigger lots, and drain problems on older septic systems. Because the north end faces Charlotte Harbor, wind-driven spray reaches further inland here than you might expect.

Manufactured and mobile homes

Mobile homes are common at both ends of the island, and their plumbing is built differently from a site-built house. Supply and drain lines run under the floor inside the skirting, usually with flexible connectors at fixtures and a water heater in a small closet that opens from outside or from a utility room.

What we check first

  • Supply piping material. Manufactured homes from roughly the late 1970s through the mid 1990s were often plumbed with gray polybutylene. It fails at fittings and from the inside out, and insurers on the island ask about it. See our polybutylene replacement page.
  • The connection at the stand pipe. The riser coming out of the ground and the line up into the home take the most abuse from settling, wind and anyone crawling under the skirting.
  • Drain slope under the floor. Long horizontal drain runs hung from the frame sag over time. A sag holds water and solids, and on septic that shows up as a slow tub or a gurgling toilet.
  • Water heater pan and relief line. In a small closet, a missing pan or a relief line that drains nowhere can rot the floor before anyone notices.

After Ian, some homes in Bokeelia shifted on their foundations. When a manufactured home moves even a few inches, the supply riser and the main drain connection are the first things to break. If your home was re-set or re-tied, have the connections looked at before you turn the water back on at full pressure.

Water from the Greater Pine Island Water Association

Both communities buy water from the Greater Pine Island Water Association, the member-owned utility that runs a reverse osmosis plant on Stringfellow Road. Its system runs down the middle of a long, narrow island, so a single break affects a big area. A line break at Pine Island Center once put the whole northern half of the island under a boil water notice, all the way up to the north end of Bokeelia. Problems at the main on Stringfellow south of the plant have done the same thing to St. James City.

When the notice lifts, the utility’s main is clean, but your house plumbing still holds water from the bad period. This is what we tell homeowners at either end:

  • Run each cold tap for several minutes, starting with the fixture closest to the meter and working toward the farthest one.
  • Throw out ice from the ice maker and run a few cycles through the refrigerator water dispenser.
  • Replace under-sink and refrigerator filters if the manufacturer says to after contamination.
  • If water came back with air and sediment, take the aerators off faucets and rinse them. Sediment also settles in the bottom of the water heater, so flushing the tank is worth doing.
  • If one fixture stays weak after everything else clears up, the cartridge or supply stop likely caught debris. That’s a small repair, not a utility problem.

If the street has water but your house doesn’t, the trouble is between the meter and the house. That’s our side. Call (239) 518-4198.

Septic on small canal lots

Lee County sewers Matlacha, and the county built a regional wastewater plant on Pine Island, but most homes in St. James City and Bokeelia are still on septic. The island’s community planning documents single out St. James City, Bokeelia and Flamingo Bay as the places with the highest risk of septic failure, because small lots back right up to saltwater canals. The plan has called for testing tanks and drainfields along those canals and studying central sewer for Bokeelia, St. James City and Pine Island Center. So far, that’s a study, not a hookup date.

On a canal lot with a high water table, the drainfield doesn’t have much dry soil to work with. After a week of summer rain, or a king tide that pushes the canal up, the field can stop taking water. The house drains then back up even though nothing is broken.

How we sort a septic problem from a drain problem

  • We ask when it happens. Backups that line up with heavy rain or high tide point toward the drainfield. Backups any time of day point toward a clog or a broken line.
  • We find the cleanout and check whether water is standing in it. Standing water at the cleanout with a clear line beyond it says the tank or field is full.
  • We run a sewer camera from the cleanout to the tank inlet. Older lines on these lots often have cracked cast iron, root intrusion from mangroves or sea grape, or a joint that separated during the storm.
  • If the house side checks out, we tell you so and pass along what we found to your septic contractor. Pumping or repairing the tank and drainfield is their work, not ours.

One more note for canal homeowners: don’t let anyone hydro jet a line straight into a septic tank that’s already full. You’ll just push solids into the drainfield.

Elevated homes and the rebuild rules

Since Ian, a lot of St. James City lots have new houses on pilings or tall stem walls, and more are coming as older homes are replaced. Bokeelia has its share too. These homes put the plumbing in a different place, and the county rules are specific about it.

Under Lee County’s flood rules, when a home in a flood zone starting with A or V has to come into compliance, the lowest floor goes to or above freeboard, which the county defines as base flood elevation plus one foot. Bathrooms, laundry rooms and mechanical equipment have to be at or above that level too. Below it, only parking, building access and limited storage are allowed. Plans for homes in V zones have to be certified by a registered engineer or architect.

For the plumbing, that means:

  • The water heater goes up in the living space or on an elevated platform that meets the elevation, not on the slab under the house.
  • No ground-level bathroom or laundry in the enclosed area below the flood level. If an older home has one, it can come up for discussion during any major permit.
  • Supply and drain lines drop through the open area under the house. Exposed PEX should not be left in sunlight, since UV breaks it down, so runs below the house are usually sleeved, boxed in or done in a material rated for the exposure.
  • Drain stacks need a cleanout you can reach at grade, and every pipe strap down there should be stainless or coated.

If an older home has a ground-level fixture that has to pump up to the drain line, our sewage ejector pump page explains what a proper setup looks like.

The 50 percent rule and your plumbing scope

Lee County applies the FEMA substantial improvement and substantial damage rule in unincorporated areas, which includes both of these communities. If the cost of repairs or improvements reaches 50 percent of the structure’s market value, the whole building has to be brought up to current flood standards. That includes elevation.

A few details that matter when plumbing is part of the job:

  • The county starts with the structure value from the Property Appraiser, not counting land. If you think it’s low, you can hire a Florida-licensed appraiser for a separate valuation.
  • Damage from any cause counts, not just flood. Wind and water damage from Ian both went into the same total.
  • Plumbing repairs and fixture replacements count toward the cost. Permits, plans, surveys, pools, fences and sheds don’t.
  • The county uses a detailed cost breakdown signed by the contractor for projects near the line. We can give you an itemized plumbing scope to include in that package.

This is one reason we prefer to look at the whole plumbing system before quoting a big repair on an older island home. If a repipe, water heater move and bathroom remodel are all coming at once, you want to know how that adds up against the threshold before anyone pulls a permit. Plumbing permits for both communities go through Lee County, since neither has its own building department.

What Ian did at each end

Ian came across the south end of the island with winds around 155 mph and a storm surge reported at more than 10 feet in St. James City. Boats ended up in yards along Monroe Canal, and some houses collapsed while the ones next door stood. Pine Island Road washed out near Matlacha, so for days the only way on or off was by boat. Months later, some St. James City residents were still living in tents and trailers on their lots.

At the north end, the damage leaned more toward wind. In Bokeelia’s mobile home communities, roofs peeled, sheds disappeared and at least one home moved off its foundation. Restoring water came first, and homes with intact lines got water back before the rest.

That pattern tells you where to look on your own house:

  • South end, surge flooded: water heaters, softeners and well equipment that sat under water; sand and silt in the house drain and septic inlet; supply lines torn from piling-mounted brackets.
  • North end, wind damaged: roof and vent pipe damage letting water into walls, broken supply risers under mobile homes, outdoor showers and hose bibs knocked loose by debris.
  • Both: leaks that only show up when the house sits at full pressure for a while. A water meter that keeps turning with everything off is the easy test.

For storm prep and the post-storm walkthrough, use our hurricane plumbing checklist for Southwest Florida. A gas or electric water heater that was submerged in salt water should be replaced, not dried out.

Salt exposure at the tips of the island

The middle of Pine Island has some buffer from the open water. The tips don’t. St. James City faces San Carlos Bay and the Gulf passes, and Bokeelia takes wind straight off Charlotte Harbor. Exterior plumbing at both ends wears faster than it does even in Matlacha.

The specific things we replace most often out here: hose bibs with seized stems, brass ball valves that won’t turn, outdoor shower valves, corroded relief lines on outdoor water heaters, and galvanized nipples where copper meets steel. Exposed copper under stilt homes goes green fast. Most of the time it’s surface oxidation, but a fitting with crusty white or green buildup at a joint is often weeping.

Use stainless hardware wherever a strap or clamp is exposed. Put a hose bib where it’s sheltered from direct spray if the layout allows. And turn your main shutoff a couple of times a year so it still works when you need it. Our hose bib repair page covers replacement valve options.

Getting to you, and planning the visit

St. James City is about 17 miles by road from the middle of Cape Coral and 26 miles from downtown Fort Myers, where our office is. Bokeelia is in the other direction, 7 miles north of Pine Island Center. Every visit means crossing the Matlacha bridges and driving Stringfellow Road, and there’s no plumbing supply house at either end. A missing part can turn a one-trip job into two.

We can’t promise a response time to the tips of the island, but we can make the trip count. When you call, it helps to have:

  • Your street and whether you’re on a canal, inland lot or in a park community.
  • Whether the house is on a slab, pilings or a manufactured home frame.
  • Photos of the problem, the water heater label and anything leaking.
  • Where your septic tank lid and main shutoff are, if you know.
  • Who can let us in if the home is empty.

Office hours are Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm. Outside those hours we take urgent calls by phone when we can. If you also own on the mainland, our Cape Coral plumber page covers the city side, and the Lee County plumber page covers the rest of the county.

Homes that sit empty half the year

With close to 4 in 10 homes at each end listed as vacant in the census, a lot of island plumbing problems are found late. A drip under a mobile home or a running toilet in a canal house can go for weeks. On septic, a long-running leak also floods the drainfield, so the owner comes back to a slow house and a smell in the yard.

Before you leave, shut off the main or install an automatic shutoff valve, set the water heater to vacation or turn it off, and arrange for someone to check the home after any storm or long outage. Our seasonal home plumbing checklist has the full list. HomeFlow also offers an annual plumbing maintenance plan, which is a yearly check-up of the plumbing system. Call us for details on how it would work for your island home.

Common Questions

Are St. James City and Bokeelia part of Cape Coral?

No. Both are unincorporated communities on Pine Island in Lee County. Plumbing permits and inspections go through Lee County, and water comes from the Greater Pine Island Water Association, not the City of Cape Coral.

Is there city sewer in St. James City or Bokeelia?

Most homes at both ends are on septic. Lee County provides sewer in Matlacha and has studied central sewer for Bokeelia, St. James City and Pine Island Center, but if you aren’t already connected, plan on your septic system for now.

My drains back up only after heavy rain or high tide. What’s going on?

On a canal lot that usually means the drainfield is saturated and can’t take water. We can check the house drain and camera the line to the tank to rule out a break or clog. If the line is clear, the tank or drainfield needs a septic contractor.

Do I need to move my water heater when I rebuild?

If your home is being brought into compliance under Lee County’s flood rules, mechanical equipment has to be at or above freeboard, which is base flood elevation plus one foot. In practice that means the water heater goes up into the living level, not under the house.

Does plumbing work count toward the 50 percent rule?

Yes. Plumbing repairs, fixtures and equipment are part of the improvement cost Lee County compares to the structure’s value. We can give you an itemized plumbing scope for the county’s cost breakdown.

I have a mobile home in Bokeelia with gray plastic pipe. Should I replace it?

Gray plastic supply pipe in a home from the late 1970s to mid 1990s is often polybutylene, which is known to fail at fittings. Many insurers won’t cover it. Replacing it with PEX is a common job in manufactured homes.

How do I know if a leak is mine or the water association’s?

Close every fixture and look at your meter. If it’s still moving, the leak is on your side. If your neighbors are out of water too, or there’s a boil water notice, call the Greater Pine Island Water Association first.

Need a plumber?

Call (239) 518-4198 or send us a request and we’ll get back to you.

Scroll to Top